Nathan Lear

Partner & Wealth Adviser

Turning Down the Noise: Why Staying Invested Matters More Than Timing the Market

17 Nov 2026

Turning Down the Noise: Why Staying Invested Matters More Than Timing the Market

There is rarely a shortage of reasons for investors to feel nervous. Whether it’s uncertainty surrounding the US midterm elections, concerns about an artificial intelligence (AI) investment bubble, geopolitical tensions or the direction of interest rates, financial headlines can make even experienced investors question whether now is the time to reduce their exposure to sharemarkets.

In recent conversations with clients, I’ve noticed these concerns becoming increasingly common. While understandable, it’s worth remembering that uncertainty is not unusual in investing. In fact, it’s a constant.

The challenge of market timing

When markets appear uncertain, moving investments into cash can feel like a sensible way to protect wealth. However, this introduces a challenge that investors often underestimate.

Successfully timing the market requires making two decisions: when to sell and, perhaps more importantly, when to reinvest.

Consider an investor concerned about elevated sharemarket valuations who decides to sell their equities and move into cash.

What happens if the market subsequently rises by 10%?

Do they reinvest at higher prices, effectively acknowledging that their decision was premature? Or do they continue waiting for a correction, potentially missing further gains?

Alternatively, imagine the market falls 10% following their decision to sell. While initially feeling vindicated, are they confident enough to reinvest? Or do concerns about further declines keep them on the sidelines?

This highlights one of the greatest challenges of market timing. The same uncertainty that encourages investors to sell often prevents them from reinvesting.

The cost of missing out

History demonstrates that sharemarkets have rewarded patient investors over the long term, despite experiencing numerous periods of volatility, economic downturns and geopolitical uncertainty.

Research also shows that missing even a relatively small number of the market’s strongest trading days can significantly reduce long-term investment returns.

Importantly, some of the strongest market recoveries occur during periods of heightened uncertainty, often when investor confidence remains low.

Waiting until the outlook feels comfortable can therefore mean missing a meaningful portion of the recovery.

Staying invested doesn’t mean doing nothing

Of course, remaining invested doesn’t mean ignoring risks or maintaining the same portfolio regardless of changing circumstances.

At Hewison Private Wealth, we believe in maintaining appropriately diversified portfolios, regularly reviewing investment exposures and rebalancing where necessary. Holding suitable cash reserves is also important, particularly for investors who require income or have shorter-term capital needs.

The objective isn’t to eliminate volatility, which is an unavoidable part of investing, but to manage risk while remaining focused on long-term financial goals.

Focus on what you can control

There will always be another election, economic concern or market event dominating the headlines. While these developments deserve consideration, allowing short-term noise to dictate long-term investment decisions can be costly.

Rather than attempting to predict the next market movement, investors are generally better served by maintaining a disciplined strategy aligned with their objectives.

If you’d like to review your investment strategy or discuss how your portfolio is positioned, we’d welcome the opportunity to start a conversation.

Sign up for the latest news and insights

This website uses cookies to enhance your overall experience. We also take your privacy very seriously.